How to Make New Haven Style Pizza at Home

New Haven apizza at home: a long cold-fermented dough, a thin charred oblong crust, tomato pie with grated pecorino, optional mozz, and the white clam pie. Recipe, oven setup and timings.

Short answer: New Haven style pizza (apizza) is a thin, chewy, heavily charred crust stretched into a rough oblong and baked very hot. To make it at home, use a wet, cold-fermented dough (24–72 hours), a pizza steel at 550°F plus the broiler, and top it the New Haven way: crushed tomato, grated Pecorino Romano, oregano and olive oil, with mozzarella only if you ask for it.

What New Haven pizza is

New Haven, Connecticut, has its own pizza tradition brought by Italian immigrants from around Naples. The famous names are Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (1925), Modern Apizza (1934) and Sally's Apizza (1938). Locals call it apizza, said roughly “ah-BEETZ.”

  • Crust: thin, crisp at the edge, chewy inside, with real black char (“not burnt, it's apizza”).
  • Shape: an irregular oblong, served on a sheet tray, cut into uneven pieces.
  • Oven: traditionally coal-fired brick ovens running far hotter than a home oven.
  • Cheese: a “plain” pie has grated hard cheese, not mozzarella. Mozzarella, called “mootz,” is an extra.

New Haven pizza dough (two 14–16 inch pies)

IngredientWeightBaker's %
Bread flour (12–13% protein)500 g100%
Cold water335 g67%
Fine salt12 g2.4%
Instant yeast1.5 g (½ tsp)0.3%
Sugar (optional, helps browning in a home oven)5 g1%
  1. Mix flour, yeast and sugar, add the water, and stir until no dry flour remains. Rest 20 minutes.
  2. Add the salt and knead 6–8 minutes until smooth. The dough will be soft and slightly sticky. That is what gives the open, chewy crumb.
  3. Bulk ferment 1 hour at room temperature, then refrigerate the whole mass, covered, for 24–72 hours. Longer means more flavour and better blistering.
  4. Ball into two pieces of about 425 g, 3–4 hours before baking, and leave covered at room temperature.

Set up your oven

  1. Put a pizza steel (or thick stone) on the top rack, 4–6 inches below the broiler.
  2. Heat to the highest setting, usually 550°F (290°C), for a full 60 minutes.
  3. Switch to broil 5 minutes before launching the pizza so the steel gets an extra blast of top heat.

Outdoor pizza ovens (Ooni, Gozney and similar) at 700–800°F get much closer to real New Haven char. Bake 2–3 minutes and turn often.

Steel or stone for New Haven char?

Steel, if you are buying one. A home oven tops out around 550°F, far below a coal oven, so what matters is how fast the baking surface pushes heat into the dough. Steel conducts heat much better than a ceramic (cordierite) stone, so it browns and chars the bottom faster. King Arthur Baking's 2026 comparison comes to the same conclusion.

Pizza steelPizza stone
Heat into the crustFast: darker, crisper bottomSlower: lighter, softer bottom
DurabilityPractically indestructibleCan crack, especially with sudden temperature changes
WeightHeavy: a 16-inch, ¼-inch steel is around 15–18 lbLighter, easier to move
CareScrape, wipe, and keep lightly oiled so it does not rustScrape and brush. No soap, do not soak

Either way, preheat for a full hour. King Arthur suggests aiming for a surface of at least 500°F, which you can check with an infrared thermometer. Give the steel or stone about 5 minutes to recover between pizzas, or each pie comes out paler than the last. Buy a rectangle as big as your oven fits. It suits New Haven's oblong shape better than a round. You can leave a steel in the oven all the time; the oven just takes longer to preheat.

Peel: a wooden peel is easier for launching wet New Haven dough, because dough sticks to wood less. A thin metal peel is better for turning and pulling the pizza out. Many home cooks keep one of each.

For a home-oven New Haven setup: a ¼-inch steel about 16 × 14 inches fits most ovens, plus a 14- or 16-inch peel.

Affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Price and delivery are shown on Amazon.

Classic tomato pie (“plain”)

  • ½ cup crushed tomatoes (hand-crushed whole San Marzano-style or good canned), seasoned with a pinch of salt
  • 3 tablespoons finely grated Pecorino Romano
  • ½ teaspoon dried oregano
  • 1 tablespoon olive oil
  • Optional: 3–4 oz low-moisture mozzarella (“mootz”) torn into small pieces
  1. Stretch the dough into a rough oblong about 14 × 10 inches on a floured peel. Keep it thin; leave only a narrow rim.
  2. Spread the tomato thinly, almost to the edge. Sprinkle the pecorino and oregano, drizzle the oil, add mozz if using.
  3. Launch onto the steel. Bake 6–8 minutes at 550°F, using the broiler for the last 1–2 minutes until the rim is blistered and spotted black.
  4. Slide onto a sheet tray or board and cut into uneven pieces.

White clam pie

New Haven's most famous pie has no tomato and no mozzarella.

  • 8–10 fresh littleneck clams, shucked and roughly chopped (or one 6.5 oz can of chopped clams, well drained)
  • 2–3 garlic cloves, finely chopped
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • ½ teaspoon dried oregano
  • 3 tablespoons grated Pecorino Romano
  • Lemon wedges to serve (optional; purists argue about it)

Brush the stretched dough with the oil and garlic, scatter the clams, oregano and pecorino, and bake exactly like the tomato pie. Fresh clams taste much brighter than canned. If you use canned, drain them hard so the crust does not go soggy.

Other New Haven orders

PieWhat is on it
Plain / tomato pieTomato, grated pecorino, oregano, oil
MootzPlain plus mozzarella
White clamClams, garlic, oregano, oil, pecorino
Sausage, pepperoni, onionAdded on top of a plain or mootz pie
Potato pie (Sally's)Thin potato slices, rosemary, oil, cheese (seasonal)

Troubleshooting

  • No char: the steel was not hot enough or too far from the broiler. Preheat longer and move it up.
  • Soggy middle: too much tomato or wet mozzarella. New Haven pies are lightly sauced.
  • Dough tears: it is still cold. Give it another hour at room temperature.
  • Crust tough, not chewy: add 1–2% more water next time, or ferment longer.

Related: copycat Domino's dough for a softer, sweeter crust, and what EVO means on pizza.

Sources and how we checked

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes New Haven pizza different?

A thin, chewy, heavily charred crust baked in a very hot coal or oil-fired oven, an irregular oblong shape, and a 'plain' tomato pie with grated cheese where mozzarella ('mootz') is an extra.

What is 'apizza'?

The New Haven word for pizza, from Neapolitan dialect, pronounced roughly 'ah-BEETZ'.

Does New Haven pizza have mozzarella?

Not by default. A plain tomato pie is crushed tomato, grated Pecorino Romano, oregano and olive oil. You ask for mozzarella ('mootz') as a topping.

What is New Haven white clam pizza?

A pie with no tomato sauce and no mozzarella: fresh chopped clams, garlic, oregano, olive oil and grated Pecorino Romano. Frank Pepe's made it famous.

Can you make New Haven pizza in a home oven?

Yes. Use a pizza steel on the top rack at your oven's highest setting (usually 550°F), finish under the broiler, and accept a slightly less charred crust.

Is a pizza steel or a pizza stone better for New Haven pizza?

A steel. Steel moves heat into the dough faster than a ceramic stone, so a home oven gets closer to New Haven char, and it will not crack. A stone still works if you preheat it for a full hour.

Can you leave a pizza steel in the oven?

Yes. Many people keep it on a rack all the time. It only means the oven takes longer to preheat, because the steel has to heat up too.