How to Pass the Stewards Challenge in Good Pizza, Great Pizza

How to pass the Stewards of Sacred Ingredients challenges in Good Pizza, Great Pizza: the first plain, vegetarian and meat pizzas, each Steward's riddle order, and what you unlock.

Short answer: The Stewards of Sacred Ingredients arrive in Chapter 2 of Good Pizza, Great Pizza. Their first test is three pizzas: one plain (sauce and cheese only), one vegetarian (vegetables, no meat) and one with meat. After that, each Steward comes alone with a riddle order about their ingredient. Read the riddle literally, keep the pizza simple, and you unlock new ingredients like bacon, ham, pineapple and wheat dough.

Game updates sometimes change dialogue and order. The approach below still works: work out which ingredient the Steward is describing, then build the simplest pizza that obviously fits.

The first group challenge

The Stewards first visit as a group and ask for “one plain, one vegetarian, one with meat.”

PizzaWhat to put on itCommon mistake
PlainSauce + cheese. Nothing else.Adding any topping, even basil or olives
VegetarianSauce + cheese + vegetables you own (onion, pepper, olive, mushroom and so on)One slice of pepperoni sneaking in
MeatSauce + cheese + pepperoni and/or sausageToo few pieces. Cover the pizza evenly

Spread toppings evenly over the whole pizza and make sure the cheese covers the sauce. The Stewards judge like normal customers, so a messy pizza can still cost you.

The individual Stewards

After the group visit, Stewards come one at a time. Each order is a riddle about an ingredient:

Steward / orderWhat it meansSafe answer
“Reveal your destiny”An open choiceAny well-made pizza: full cheese, even toppings, cooked properly
Fish / “deserted beach” orderAnchoviesSauce, cheese and anchovies spread evenly (follow the half/whole wording in the order)
“Grown from the ground” / herbsVegetables or basilSauce, cheese and vegetables or basil only, no meat
Meat StewardMeat toppingsSeveral meats across the pizza; read whether they want one side or all of it
Fruit StewardPineappleSauce, cheese and pineapple
Wheat StewardWheat doughA simple pizza on the dough they ask for

How to read a riddle order

  1. Find the one ingredient. Every Steward guards one thing. Their order points at it.
  2. Check “half” and “side”. If the dialogue says half, put toppings on exactly half. Use the cut lines as a guide.
  3. Do not decorate. Extra ingredients the riddle does not ask for are the most common way to fail.
  4. Bake and cut properly. Under-baked or badly cut pizzas lose points even if the toppings are right.

What you unlock

Passing the Stewards gives you access to new ingredients, including bacon, ham, pineapple and wheat dough, which appears in the shop to buy after you finish the challenge. Completing the Steward storyline is also part of reaching Chapter 3.

If you fail

A failed Steward usually comes back on a later day with the same order. Make sure you own the ingredient they hint at before they return. Buy it in the shop if you are missing it. Then play it straight: simple, even, fully cooked.

Another pizza game: Hello Kitty Island Adventure pizza recipes.

More pizza questions answered: what is cini on pizza and how many slices in a large pizza.

Sources and how we checked

Frequently Asked Questions

What do the Stewards want in their first challenge?

Three pizzas: one plain (sauce and cheese), one vegetarian (vegetables only, no meat) and one with meat.

Who are the Stewards in Good Pizza, Great Pizza?

The Stewards of Sacred Ingredients are a secret group of customers who appear in Chapter 2. Each one guards an ingredient and tests you with a riddle order.

What do you get for passing the Stewards challenges?

New ingredients such as bacon, ham, pineapple and wheat dough, and progress toward Chapter 3.

Can I retry a Stewards challenge?

If you fail, the Steward usually returns on a later day with the same request, so you get another try.