Short answer: Heat the oven to 375°F (190°C) with a baking sheet inside. Put the slices on the hot sheet and bake 6–8 minutes (a whole pizza 8–10 minutes) until the cheese bubbles and the bottom is crisp. Do not put the cardboard box in the oven.
Step by step
- Preheat the oven and the tray together at 375°F (190°C) for 10–15 minutes. A hot tray crisps the bottom the way a pizza oven does.
- Take the pizza out of the fridge while the oven heats.
- Put the slices on the hot tray with a little space between them. For the crispest base, put them straight on the rack with foil on the rack below to catch drips.
- Bake 6–8 minutes for slices or 8–10 minutes for a whole pie.
- Check the bottom. Lift a slice with a spatula. It should be firm and dry, not bendy.
Times by crust
| Papa John's crust | Oven | Time | Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original hand-tossed | 375°F / 190°C | 6–8 min | Preheated tray |
| Thin crust | 350°F / 175°C | 4–6 min | Burns fast; check at 4 |
| Pan crust | 375°F / 190°C | 8–10 min | Foil tent for the first half so the top does not dry out |
| Stuffed crust / Epic crust | 350°F / 175°C | 10–12 min | Lower heat so the cheese in the rim melts through |
| Whole pizza (any crust) | 375°F / 190°C | 8–10 min | On a tray, not in the box |
Reheat temps: oven, air fryer, toaster oven, skillet, microwave
These work for any delivery or leftover pizza, not just Papa John's. Times are for chilled slices from the fridge. Whatever the method, the USDA says leftovers should reach 165°F (74°C) in the center.
| Method | Setting | Time (slices) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oven | 375°F / 190°C, preheated tray | 6–8 min (whole pizza 8–10) | Crisp base, evenly hot. Best for more than 3 slices |
| Air fryer | 350°F / 175°C, one layer | 3–4 min | Fastest crisp base; check thin crust at 2–3 min |
| Toaster oven | 375°F / 190°C, on the tray | 4–6 min | Like the oven, for 1–2 slices. Use the tray, not the bare rack, so cheese does not drip onto the element |
| Skillet | Medium heat, dry pan, then lid | 2 min uncovered + 1 min covered | Very crisp bottom. Add a few drops of water beside the slice before the lid goes on, to melt the cheese |
| Microwave | High, plate loosely covered with a paper towel | 30–45 sec | Hot but soft and chewy. Fine for a quick slice |
From frozen, add a few minutes: about 10–12 minutes in a 375°F oven. Above about 425°F the cheese burns before the middle warms through.
The garlic sauce
Papa John's garlic dipping sauce is mostly oil and solidifies in the fridge. Do not microwave it in the plastic cup. Pour some into a small bowl and warm it 10–15 seconds, or leave it out while the pizza reheats. You can also brush a little on the crust edge before reheating for a garlic-bread finish.
Mistakes to avoid
- Box in the oven. Cardboard can char or catch fire.
- Cold oven. Putting pizza in before the oven is hot dries the toppings before the base crisps.
- Too hot. Above 425°F the cheese burns before the middle is warm.
- Covering it with foil the whole time. It steams instead of crisping. Only tent pan pizza, and only for half the time.
Storing leftovers
Put leftovers in the fridge within 2 hours of delivery, in a sealed container or wrapped well, not in the box. Eat within 3–4 days and reheat until hot in the middle (165°F / 74°C). Slices can be frozen for 1–2 months (how to freeze pizza properly); reheat from frozen at 375°F for 10–12 minutes.
Related: reheating a Taco Bell Mexican Pizza, how many slices in a Papa John's large.